Partnership You Can Feel. Expertise You Can Trust.
As the largest independent agent in the Greater Pittsburgh region, Henderson Brothers represents the most established and respected insurance carriers. Our long-standing relationships and knowledgeable staff ensure that our customers receive the finest products and services available today.
Where Expertise Meets Personalized Insurance Solutions
We are insurance experts dedicated to protecting what matters most.
We design and manage customized, competitive insurance solutions for leading corporations, nonprofit organizations, small businesses, and individuals. With experience across a wide range of industries, our team tailors coverage to your unique goals and goes to heroic lengths to deliver peace of mind.
What We Deliver
Experience
Our experts bring unparalleled knowledge to navigating complex risks and protecting what matters most.
Partnership
We go beyond advising—working side by side with our clients as true partners to deliver proactive, personalized solutions.
Excellence
Every engagement reflects our commitment to high standards, tailored programs, and a level of service that consistently exceeds expectations.
Our Vision
We will continue to be an independently owned insurance agency. We will anticipate our customers’ needs and go to heroic lengths to service their business.
Our Mission
We will maintain our position as a respected leader in our industry by providing the best insurance protection, service and value for our customers.
“Henderson Brothers employees are very knowledgeable and understanding. When presented with questions they are quick to respond. We would recommend Henderson Brothers to our clients or anyone that is in need of a broker.”
Guided by Experience. Driven by Service.
A History of Trust
Since its founding in 1893 as a steamboat packet line on the Ohio River, Henderson Brothers has evolved over more than 130 years into a trusted, family-owned and independent insurance, employee-benefits, and financial health solutions firm that has expanded its services and footprint while building long-term relationships rooted in trust, expertise, and client-focused service. Explore Our History →
A Commitment to Excellence: World-Class Client Satisfaction
We believe the best measure of our success is the experience of our clients. In partnership with Satrix Solutions, an independent research firm, we use the Net Promoter Score® (NPS) to measure client satisfaction and loyalty. In 2026, Henderson Brothers earned a 77 NPS, placing us in the world-class category, with 81% of clients indicating they are likely to continue working with us. These results reflect the trust, value, and partnership our clients experience every day.
A Dedication to Community
As a multigenerational family business, we believe strong communities create a brighter future for everyone. We’re committed to enriching the lives of the people who make our region unique. Our dedication to service continues beyond the workday through everyday kindness, charitable involvement, and support for the friends, families, neighbors, and causes that inspire us.
Talk to a Business Insurance Advisor Today
Experience the Power of Partnership
Contact Henderson Brothers at 412-261-1842, or click Request Consultation below to connect with a commercial insurance advisor.
